Tuesday, February 9, 2010

I really should start posting these before class, so that I don't end up reiterating everything that's already been said.

We discussed in class all the different takes on children and adults in Peter Pan but we didn't really address the pirates to any extent. I think the pirates were some of the most intriguing characters in the book. To me, they're sort of like over-grown children-- they are still searching for a mother and they're stuck in this Neverland of imagination, constantly chasing around children (or are they chasing after their childhoods?). Captain Hook is already an adult, but he's a very different sort of adult. It's interesting, to me, that he's usually played by Mr. Darling, a man we've established as another over-grown child. Perhaps, by having Mrs. Darling play the figure (as Barrie originally intended), we would see that the mother figure is the one chasing after her childhood. She did save that kiss on the corner of her mouth just for Peter Pan (at least, he's the only one who could take it), and, like Hook, she cannot defeat the passage of time that will take away her own children. Just as Captain Hook does, Mrs. Darling both fears and admires Peter Pan (though, in her motherly state, she's not nearly so violent about it). The night Peter comes and takes the children to Neverland, Mrs. Darling struggles to leave for their party because "a nameless fear clutched at her heart"-- she's scared of him. At the same time, though, she vaguely remembers him from her own childhood; she saved a kiss for him. They have different motives for their fear of Peter, but there are some remarkable-- if a little stretched-- similarities between Hook and Mrs. Darling.

Now back to the pirates. They seem to be the grown-up versions (and by "grown-up" I simply mean "older") of the Lost Boys. They, too, long for mothers and they also dwell in the land of fantasy, which is generally only associated with chidlren. We established in class that, in this book, children need adults and adults need children. The way the pirates and Lost Boys are positioned, though, the adults are fighting against the children and the children are fighting against the adults. Couple all of this with the ticking crocodile and opening line that "All children, except one, grow up" and you have what could be an incredibly symbolic relationship. Perhaps the children are fighting their future selves (I especially see the similarities between Tootles and Smee and Peter and Hook) or perhaps the pirates are fighting their own child-like natures. After all, a child without a mother can easily grow up to be a scoundrel (or a pirate) and an adult who matured in body but not mind can certainly be obsessed with children (perhaps like Barrie himself). Hook, himself, is especially jealous at the ease and cockiness the children possess. He hates that they effortlessly embody good form while he has to try for it. The kids hate him because he represents what they will all (except Peter) turn in to. I think Hook especially hates Peter because he'll never grow up; Peter will never experience what it's like to have time, even in the form of a crocodile, chasing after him. Hook wants Wendy as a mother because only children rely on mothers; perhaps he sees her as an avenue for getting back what he's lost as an adult. At any rate, he learns the hard way that he can't go back as time has already chosen him as its next victim.

I feel like I'm putting forth too many ideas. I'm starting to get confused, so I think I need to stop. Needless to say, this book has always fascinated me; there's so much to be said about it and, at the same time, so much that shouldn't be said.

2 comments:

  1. You have some really great points here! I like what you said about pirates chasing their own childhoods, and I think you have some solid evidence with the comparisons to the lost boys. Great post!

    ReplyDelete
  2. oooo! I like your post! I like thinking about the fighting between the lost boys and the pirates as being a metaphor for an internal battle between childhood and adulthood! ... And who wins in the end? I wonder what Barrie is trying to tell us about the dominant nature of humanity, as he sees it.

    ReplyDelete